Comparison of AdvanSync2® and Twin Block Appliances in Treatment of Class II Malocclusion With Retrognathic Mandible—An Observational Retrospective Study

Hey tooth warriors! 🦷💥 Today, we’re diving into the world of Class II malocclusion—aka when the upper jaw says, “I’m moving ahead,” and the lower jaw whispers, “Wait for me!” 😅

This condition happens when there’s a mismatch in jaw positioning—either the lower jaw is shy (mandibular retrusion)or the upper jaw is a bit too bold (maxillary prognathism). But spoiler alert: most of the time, it’s the mandible lagging behind. 🐢

🎯 GROWING PATIENTS = GROWING OPPORTUNITIES

If your patient’s still growing (yay puberty! 🎉), you’ve got options to guide those jaws like a dental GPS:

  • Functional appliances = Tell the mandible, “Come on buddy, time to move forward.” 🦷➡️
  • Headgear = Tap the brakes on that upper jaw growth. 🛑👃

👉 These options work best before the growth spurt ends, so early detection is key!

👄 REMOVABLE VS. FIXED APPLIANCES – THE BATTLE BEGINS ⚔️

We’ve got two major contenders:

1. Twin Block (Removable Champ)

  • Invented by Clark (nope, not Superman 🦸).
  • Worn like retainers—you can pop them in and out. 😬
  • Works like a charm when patients actually wear them (compliance alert 🚨).
  • Great for boosting mandibular growth and improving jaw harmony. 🎵

2. AdvanSync2® (Fixed Fighter)

  • glow-up of the classic Herbst appliance.
  • Created by the Dischinger duo in 2008 (dental bros! 👨‍🔬👨‍🔬).
  • Cemented on molars (yep, no backing out now 😅).
  • Works full-time (24/7 hustle 😤) with telescopic rods to push that mandible forward.
  • Bonus: You can slap on braces while using it! 💪

Wait… what happened to the original Herbst?

Well, it kinda had a bad rep:

  • Bulky 🙄
  • Cheek-poking parts 😵
  • Maintenance nightmare 🪛

So, enter AdvanSync2®—smaller, sleeker, and less ouch-y! 🙌

🤓 WHY THIS STUDY MATTERS:

Most past studies compared AdvanSync2® with other fixed appliances. But let’s face it—compliance with removable appliances is like relying on a teenager to do chores 🧹 (sometimes it happens, sometimes… not so much).

👉 That’s why this study asks: “What really happens when we compare Twin Block (removable) to AdvanSync2® (fixed)?”

They measured:

  • Skeletal changes (how the jaws move 🦴)
  • Dentoalveolar changes (what the teeth and surrounding structures do 🦷)
  • Soft tissue effects (how the face changes 😮)

And just to keep things scientific (and dramatic), they had a null hypothesis“No difference between the two.”

But are they really that similar? 🤔

🧪 Study Design Recap:

This was a retrospective study (no time machines, just old records), comparing 10–15 year olds at CVMI stages 2–4 (hello puberty 👋). No control group here because, ethically, you can’t just not treat a kid who needs help 😬.

👉 Group I: Twin Blockers (Avg age 12.1)
👉 Group II: AdvanSync2® gang (Avg age 12.8)

Perfect timing—just around the growth spurt, which, as Baccetti says, is the sweet spot for jaw growth magic! ✨

🧠 Cranial Base Variables

Both groups showed a little reshaping action up at the top:

  • Twin Block: +1.55° saddle angle ⛰️, -3.41° articular angle.
  • AdvanSync2®: -2.40° articular angle.

Translation? 👇
Both appliances helped bring the mandible forward relative to the cranial base—a win for both sides! 🙌

🦴 Maxillary Skeletal Variables

The whole idea here is to chill out maxillary growth (aka the “headgear effect” 😤🛑).

  • Twin Block: Co-Pt A increased a bit (+2.15 mm) due to normal growth or orthopedic stimulation, but SNA dropped slightly (−0.52°).
  • AdvanSync2®: Also showed some changes, but surprisingly, not a major maxillary growth restriction this time!

📚 PS: Other studies hyped up AdvanSync2® as a maxilla tamer… not quite here. 🤷‍♀️

😮‍💨 Mandibular Skeletal Variables – The Main Event!

Here’s where things get really spicy 🌶️

✅ Twin Block Results:

  • Co-Gn (mandibular length): +2.87 mm
  • SNB (mandible angle): +1.59°
  • Pog-N perpendicular: +0.84 mm

💬 Verdict: A decent push forward, but not groundbreaking.

✅ AdvanSync2® Results:

  • Co-Gn: A whopping +5.34 mm 📏
  • SNB: +3.11° 🎯
  • Pog-N perpendicular: +3.69 mm
  • Ar-Go (ramus length): +1.89 mm

😱 That’s some serious forward growth, folks!

📣 AdvanSync2® went full beast mode, proving why fixed appliances are often preferred when compliance is shaky. No “oops, I forgot to wear it today” moments here! 😅

🤝 Upper Jaw vs. Lower Jaw – Let’s Talk Relationships! 💬

(aka Intermaxillary Variables)

You know it’s serious when we start talking ANB angle and Wits appraisal—that’s dental code for “How far is that lower jaw lagging behind?” 🏃‍♂️💨

📉 ANB Angle + Wits = Both Took a Dive

  • Twin Block:
    🟢 ANB dropped by −2.11°
    🟢 Wits dropped by −3.09 mm
  • AdvanSync2®:
    🔵 ANB dropped even more – −2.88°
    🔵 Wits dropped more too – −4.04 mm

🎯 Translation: Both appliances moved the lower jaw forward, reducing the gap between upper and lower jaws. But hey, AdvanSync2® had a slight edge—probably thanks to that all-day, everyday action. 💪


🔍 Maxillary–Mandibular Differential (aka Who Grew More?)

  • Twin Block: +0.94 mm
  • AdvanSync2®: +2.39 mm

Why the difference? The mandible had a growth spurt, thanks to being pushed forward like a coach yelling, “Get in the game!” 🗣️🏈

💬 It’s not just growth, it’s functional ortho magic! ✨
The telescopic mechanism of AdvanSync2® = more forward jaw movement + better skeletal change. Boom. ✅


📏 Vertical Skeletal Variables – Are We Growing Up… or Just Forward?

Heads up! 📐 Let’s look at how the face stretched vertically during treatment. (Because yes, your face can grow “taller,” too!)

VariableTwin BlockAdvanSync2®What It Means 😅
Na-Me (ant. facial height)+0.63 mm+2.82 mmYou got taller. Sort of. 🧍‍♂️
S-Go (post. facial height)+1.02 mm+1.73 mmBack of the face grew, too! 🧠➡️🦷
ANS-Me (lower face)+0.96 mm+2.13 mmHello, chin drop! 🪞
Mandibular plane angle+0.89°+1.12°Slight clockwise jaw rotation 🔁

👉 So both appliances caused the lower face to elongate and the jaw to rotate a bit downward and forward.
Why? That sneaky posterior bite block in the Twin Block lifts the bite, guiding the growth downward. AdvanSync2® does similar things, just without being removable. 🛠️

Interdental and Soft Tissue Shenanigans

(Or in ortho-speak: “Did we fix the bite, and does the face care?”)

We’re wrapping up our headgear-free saga with the final act: interdental movementssoft tissue glow-ups, and what this all means for your future ortho plans. Let’s bite in! 🍴


🦷 Interdental Variables – Where the Teeth Party Happens 🎉

✅ Twin Block Group:

  • U1-L1 angle (interincisal): Dropped by −2.51° = incisors tipped toward each other 📉
  • Overjet: Reduced by −5.29 mm 😲
  • Overbite: Down by −1.48 mm
  • Molar correction: A solid +4.21 mm

💬 Why? Because Twin Block tends to retrocline upper incisors and procline lowers. The bite evens out as the jaws come together and molars do a sweet lil’ shift—maxillary molars move back, mandibular molars step forward like a bold dance move. 💃🕺


✅ AdvanSync2® Group:

  • U1-L1 angle: Went up by +2.97°, though not significantly = incisors slightly angled apart 📐
  • Overjet: Reduced by −4.60 mm
  • Overbite: Also decreased −2.27 mm
  • Molar correction: A powerful −5.18 mm

💬 So AdvanSync2® corrected molar position and bite depth quite well—just like Twin Block—but didn’t tweak those incisors as much. It’s a fixed appliance, so it works around the clock 🕒, giving it an edge with molar shifts and bite correction even when patients forget they’re wearing it. 😉


⚖️ Which Appliance Wins the Tooth Battle?

  • Overjet/Overbite/Molar Fix? ✅ Both did great!
  • Interincisal angle (U1-L1)? 🏆 Twin Block wins—more controlled incisor movement.

🦷 Moral of the story: If your patient has big overjet and deep overbite—either appliance is your pal. But if you need more precise incisor control, Twin Block might give you the edge (assuming they wear it 🤞).


👄 Soft Tissue Changes – The Face-Off (Literally) 🤳

Time to find out: Did these appliances do the orthodontic equivalent of contouring?

✅ Twin Block:

  • Upper lip to E-plane: Moved back −1.04 mm (that’s subtle retraction)
  • Lower lip: Nudged forward +0.59 mm (barely noticeable)
  • Nasolabial angle: Slightly up +2.09°

➡️ Basically: Minor lip shifts, mostly due to how the upper incisors moved back. Nothing major—think more like a light Instagram filter than a full makeover. 😅


✅ AdvanSync2®:

  • Upper lip to E-plane: Also retracted −1.68 mm
  • Lower lip: Slightly forward +1.32 mm
  • Nasolabial angle: +3.12° (again, mild)

💬 Bottom line? Not a dramatic change here either. Some studies say AdvanSync2® can puff out the lower lip, but in this study: changes weren’t significant.

📸 Takeaway: Don’t promise your patients a new selfie look—these appliances fix bites, not faces. 😄


🧪 Final Diagnosis: Who Wins the Ortho Crown? 👑

✅ Both Twin Block and AdvanSync2®:

  • Correct overjet and molar relationship beautifully
  • Promote mandibular growth
  • Deliver mild soft-tissue and vertical skeletal changes

🏆 AdvanSync2® stands out for:

  • More effective mandibular length gain
  • Greater SNB increase (hello forward jaw!)
  • No worries about compliance because… they can’t take it out 😏

🤝 Twin Block shines for:

  • More controlled incisor movement
  • Still effective—but requires that magical thing called “patient cooperation” 🙃

SUMMARY

🦴 Skeletal Changes

VariableTwin Block (Mean Change)AdvanSync2® (Mean Change)Significance
Co-Gn (mm)+2.87+5.34P < 0.01
SNB (°)+1.59+3.11P < 0.01
SNA (°)−0.52−0.04NS
Co-Pt A (mm)+2.15+3.31NS
Articular Angle (°)−3.41−2.40NS

NS = Not Significant


🦷 Dentoalveolar & Intermaxillary Effects

VariableTwin Block (Mean Change)AdvanSync2® (Mean Change)Significance
U1-L1 (°)−2.51+2.97P < 0.05
Overjet (mm)−5.29−4.60NS
Overbite (mm)−1.48−2.27NS
Molar AP (mm)−4.21−5.18NS
ANB (°)−2.11−2.88NS
Wits (mm)−3.09−4.04NS

NS = Not Significant


🧍 Soft Tissue Changes

VariableTwin Block (Mean Change)AdvanSync2® (Mean Change)Significance
Upper Lip to E-plane (mm)−1.04−1.68NS
Lower Lip to E-plane (mm)+0.59+1.32NS
Nasolabial Angle (°)+2.09+3.12NS

NS = Not Significant

Leave a comment