Questions to Ponder with Answers: Class II Division 2 – Planning and Treatment Method

1. Why is the inter-incisor angle critical to stability in Class II div 2?

  • Class II div 2 has increased inter-incisor angle
  • Excessive angle → deep overbite and mandibular locking
  • Normalizing angle:
    • Reduces vertical overlap
    • Allows lower incisors to sit in zone of balance
  • Palatal torque of upper incisors is essential
  • If angle is not corrected → lower incisors relapse

Viva punchline:
👉 Stable overbite correction depends on normalization of the inter-incisor angle.


2. Why doesn’t lower incisor advancement relapse?

  • Relapse occurs only if teeth move outside muscular envelope
  • Lower incisors are advanced:
    • Within lower lip contour
    • Not beyond soft-tissue limits
  • Simultaneous:
    • Upper incisor intrusion
    • Palatal torque
  • This unlocks the mandible
  • New incisor position becomes physiologic

Viva punchline:
👉 Because the lower incisor is advanced within the soft-tissue envelope.


3. Why is flattening the curve of Spee essential?

  • Class II div 2 → exaggerated curve of Spee
  • Lower incisor advancement creates:
    • ~4–5 mm space anteriorly
    • ~8–10 mm total
  • ~2 mm per side used for:
    • Flattening curve of Spee
  • Remaining space used for alignment
  • Flattening is part of correction, not space loss

Viva punchline:
👉 Curve of Spee flattening enables non-extraction treatment.


4. Why upper removable appliance first?

  • Achieves multiple goals simultaneously:
    • Bite opening
    • Upper incisor palatal torque
    • Buccal segment distalization
    • Correction of scissor bite
    • Upper incisor intrusion
  • Frees mandible from locked position
  • Fixed appliance alone cannot do this efficiently

Viva punchline:
👉 Upper removable appliance provides coordinated first-phase correction.


5. Importance of upper incisor centroid

  • Centroid = midpoint of incisor root
  • Helps assess:
    • Root position
    • Torque control
  • Lower incisor tip position relative to centroid determines:
    • Inter-incisor angle
    • Stability
  • Lower incisor behind centroid → unstable
  • Slightly ahead → stable relationship

Viva punchline:
👉 Centroid guides stable inter-incisor positioning.


6. When to extract? Why not first premolars?

  • Extractions only if:
    • Severe skeletal discrepancy
    • Inadequate space after leveling
  • First premolar extraction:
    • Compromises buccal segment correction
  • Second premolars preferred:
    • Maintain Class I molar correction
  • Decision after therapeutic diagnosis

Viva punchline:
👉 Extraction decisions are delayed and conservative in Class II div 2.


7. Why long-term lower bonded retainer?

  • Lower anterior relapse is unpredictable
  • Tight perioral musculature common
  • Lower anterior segment is foundation of correction
  • Bonded retainer:
    • Maintains AP and transverse position
  • Stable lower incisors support upper incisors
  • Upper arch often needs minimal retention

Viva punchline:
👉 Lower bonded retainer ensures long-term stability.


8. Role of upper incisor–lip relationship

  • Upper incisor should:
    • Contact inner slope of lower lip
    • Show 2–3 mm at rest
  • Defines soft-tissue boundary
  • Dictates:
    • Amount of intrusion
    • Palatal torque
  • Aesthetic goal = biomechanical goal

Viva punchline:
👉 Soft-tissue aesthetics guide incisor positioning.


9. Why no encroachment on lower lip?

  • Teeth outside soft-tissue envelope relapse
  • Lower lip exerts strong muscular pressure
  • Advancing beyond lip contour → instability
  • Staying within lip contour ensures:
    • Muscular support
    • Long-term stability

Viva punchline:
👉 Respecting the soft-tissue envelope prevents relapse.


10. Therapeutic diagnosis and extraction decision

  • Therapeutic diagnosis = diagnosis through treatment response
  • In Class II div 2:
    • Complete first-phase correction
    • Reassess space and alignment
  • Avoid premature extraction decisions
  • Especially useful in borderline cases

Viva punchline:
👉 Extraction is decided after observing treatment response.


Leave a comment